top of page

Halloween-Themed and Haunted Bars NYC Edition

NYC's Haunted Bar Scene – Where Spirits (the Other Kind) Like to Hang Out!

Greetings dear readers, today we explore the most haunted bars in NYC where chills, thrills, and spine-tingling spills are all on the menu. Picture this: you, surrounded by ghouls, sipping on eerie elixirs, and maybe even making a spectral friend or two. So, ditch the basic haunted house plans and join us on a tour of NYC's bars where the spirits aren't just in the cocktails.

A purple cocktail smoking from dry ice
Photo Courtesy of Loreley Beer Garden

This NYC haunted bars bucket list is broken into 2 halves, actually haunted bars and halloween-themed bars.

Actually Haunted Bars

326 Spring St, New York, NY, map

As one of the longest-running bars in NYC, it’s only logical that there would be a few spirits, right? The Ear Inn is said to be visited by the ghost of Mickey, a sailor who lived upstairs and died during Prohibition.

54 Pearl St, New York, NY 10004, map

Known for its historical significance, this tavern in the Financial District is said to have hauntings related to its colonial past. With a history as far back as the 1700s don’t be surprised if you hear a voice or two.

15 E 7th St, New York, NY, map

Step into the dimly lit abyss of McSorley's. This historic East Village pub is rumored to be haunted by a few spirits, including a pair of Civil War soldiers. Some visitors claim to have seen apparitions and experienced unexplained phenomena.

17 Barrow St, New York, NY, map

This romantic restaurant and bar in a historic carriage house is believed to be haunted by the ghost of Aaron Burr's daughter, Theodosia Burr Alston. If you sense a chill on your neck, just remember – it's all in good spirits.

567 Hudson St, New York, NY, map

Known for its literary history, this Greenwich Village bar is believed to be haunted by the spirit of poet Dylan Thomas, who spent his final hours here. Sip on your cocktail and listen closely – you might just catch a whisper of poetry in the wind.

Haunted for the Night (aka Halloween-Themed Bars)

1. Beetle House

308 E 6th St, New York, NY, map

A themed restaurant and bar known for its unique Tim Burton-inspired decor and creative cocktails. Beetle House provides a whimsical and immersive dining experience perfect for Halloween.

101 Rivington St. New York, NY, map

At the Black Lagoon popup, Pretty Ricky's has been eerily transformed into a hauntingly delightful setting, complete with a thoughtfully crafted cocktail menu featuring spooky, Halloween-themed drinks.

47 Stone St, New York, NY, map + 1 more location

Mixing magic and mixology, The Cauldron offers an immersive experience where you can concoct your own potions and elixirs in a setting that's straight out of a fantasy book.

511 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY, map

This lively neighborhood haunt has gone all in for Halloween with perfectly curated decor and even a Halloween weekend party to celebrate.

678 Woodward Ave, Queens, NY, map

Visiting the Flying Fox is like stepping into a never-ending Halloween celebration; this classic-horror-themed bar and restaurant ensures a thrilling and eerie experience that's perfect for Halloween enthusiasts, complete with special October events to up the spooky ante.

329 Lexington Ave, New York, NY, map

The Junction is fully decked out for Halloween, boasting an immersive and spooky decor with a massive dragon guarding the entrance. They offer a tempting lineup of fall cocktails, including a pumpkin spice espresso martini and blackberry Sabbath sangria, along with $5 Halloween-themed shots.

13 E 17th St, New York, NY, map + 1 more location

Already a frequent mention in our NYC Halloween coverage (see here and here), Lillie’s is a content-creator-preferred spot for a reason. All year long they serve up gorgeous IG-worthy decor, but for spooky season they go extra hard, providing the perfect Halloween-themed backdrop for your cocktail selfies.

7 Rivington St, New York, NY, map

Loreley's Halloween Haunted Beer Garden features elaborate Halloween decor, daily specials, and Halloween parties. Guests can savor Halloween-themed cocktails like the Magic Potion Margarita and Bloody IV Bag. The outdoor garden transforms into a haunted space with eerie decorations, and the festivities include a Day of the Dead Party, Barbie's World Halloween Party, and costume contests.

Text: "Read Next: Magic Hour: The Best Adult Playground for Halloween in NYC" Photo: A girl holding a cocktail while sitting on a hot pink bench with a pink and orange floral arrangement surrounding it

485 7th Ave 18th floor, New York, NY, map

We’ve written a whole post on this one so we won’t get too detailed here, but this is the perfect spot for delicious drinks and cute pics this Halloween season.

10. Sveta

64 Carmine St, New York, NY, map

Sveta launched an exciting Halloween cocktail menu, complemented by a spooky decor update, promising a captivating Halloween experience for all patrons this season.

Remember that these themes and offerings can change from year to year, so be sure to check each bar's official website or social media for the most up-to-date information on their Halloween events and offerings. Enjoy a ghoulishly good time at these Haunted and Halloween-themed bars in NYC!

You Might Also Enjoy...

If you visit any of these places don't forget to tag @popupgirlsnyc for a chance to be featured on our feed!

1 Comment

Unknown member
Dec 11, 2023

Experience Zenith Tranquility at get more information, a meticulously designed haven dedicated to elevating your holistic well-being. Immerse yourself in a carefully curated space crafted to rejuvenate your mind, body, and spirit, offering experiences dedicated to revitalizing your senses. At Jacana Wellness, the essence of self-care is seamlessly woven into every moment, inviting you to embrace a sanctuary of serenity with each visit. Rediscover balance and immerse yourself in the transformative power of well-being on a personalized journey tailored just for you. Your pathway to renewal gracefully unfolds at Jacana Wellness.

bottom of page